Stay at Old Olcott Beach Fire Station, a 4.2-rated guest house and bar in Olcott, NY. Enjoy comfortable accommodations at 1571 Lockport St with positive guest reviews.
Recent guests appreciate the comfortable and affordable accommodations paired with a welcoming atmosphere and a highly praised onsite restaurant. The property’s location and local charm add to its appeal for visitors exploring Olcott and nearby attractions.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Located at 1571 Lockport St in Olcott, NY, Old Olcott Beach Fire Station offers a blend of guest house accommodations and a bar environment. With a 4.2 rating from 76 reviews, this property appeals to travelers seeking a casual and affordable stay in a small-town setting. Guests have noted the clean and comfortable rooms as well as the friendly atmosphere throughout the property.
The on-site bar enhances the experience with a cozy and sociable setting, where bartenders and servers are described as welcoming. In addition to the bar, the Maxwell Station Restaurant is conveniently located at the same address, praised by visitors for its homemade dishes and reasonable prices. Local favorites include the French Onion Sandwich and Monday’s chicken and biscuits, reflecting a focus on fresh, comforting fare.
Guests frequently highlight the property's suitability for fishing trips and quiet getaways, appreciating the lack of commercialization in Olcott. The location offers proximity to local diners, shops, and seasonal live entertainment, providing options for both relaxation and exploring the community. The nearby lakeside views and opportunities for salmon fishing add to the appeal for outdoor enthusiasts.
While some visitors mention the initial challenge of locating staff, many commend the helpfulness once connected. The overall impression is of a well-maintained and reasonably priced place that matches the laid-back spirit of its surroundings. Old Olcott Beach Fire Station works well for small groups or individuals looking for a straightforward and hospitable stay in northern New York.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
A must stop place to eat. Great atmosphere and food. Some of the best pricing I have encountered.
The staff were friendly once you found them, the room was clean and well laid out, the food and drinks at the restaurant were good, and the price was beyond reasonable. I wholeheartedly recommend this place for any size party.
My wife and I fell in love with Olcott and the surrounding area. We have a time share in the area and cannot wait to return. We love the abscence of commercialization. I love the small diners and stores. I plan on eating at as many as I can. I am also looking forward to catching some salmon! See you soon! Oh one more thing, the live entertainment at various places around the city was cool.
Probably the best place in northern NY if you're looking for an affordable place. Don't let the price fool you. This apartment has everything including a nice beach side view upstairs! I'd definitely recommend taking this place and checking out some breakfast in town!
Couldn't have found a better place to stay for a fishing trip of a party of three! Had absolutely everything needed and than some. Restaurant on site was awesome and everyone in town was amasing and friendly.Will be back soon with wife to have a get away,and we are planning another fishing trip next year,staying at The Old Olcott Beach Firehouse,again!
Best food in Olcott! Everything is fresh and homemade. Great cozy atmosphere. Very friendly bartenders and servers. I recommend the French Onion Sandwich. It's the best sandwich ever! They also have really great chicken and biscuits on Mondays.
No complaints with facility clean room and comfortable .Food was good reasonably priced. Nice location. Friendly people
Owner is pleasant to deal with, the room we have is very nice, prices are good!
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
4.1star Days Inn by Wyndham Lisbon offers free WiFi, breakfast, parking, and onsite dining. Conveniently near downtown Lisbon a...
3.4rated extended stay hotel in Syracuse, NY with LGBTQ+ friendly amenities. Near Everson Museum, Destiny USA mall, and Rosamond ...
Stay at Moxy Cincinnati Downtown with free WiFi, restaurant, and fitness center. Steps from museums, dining, and stadiums in down...
Stay at Americas Best Value Inn Stephenville, TX. Enjoy free WiFi, breakfast, outdoor pool, and petfriendly rooms near Tarleton ...
Stay at Greenwich Inn, a 4star motel offering unfussy rooms with minifridges, free parking, and WiFi. Near Golden Gate Bridge, Al...
Relax at O'Sullivan's on the Lake Motel in Lake George, NY. Woodsy rooms, free WiFi, outdoor pool, petfriendly, and close to For...
3.9star hotel in Hope Mills, NC offering free WiFi, outdoor pool, gym, and buffet breakfast. Close to Fayetteville Regional Airp...
Stay at Residence Inn by Marriott Sacramento Folsom with spacious suites, kitchens, free WiFi, indoor pool, and close to Folsom L...
Contemporary Hilton Garden Inn West Little Rock offers free WiFi, indoor pool, gym, and petfriendly rooms. Conveniently located ...
Stay at Baymont by Wyndham Henderson Oxford with free WiFi, pool & gym. Close to Kerr Lake State Recreation Area. 519 reviews, 3....
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
